Jared Pilon
Canadian homeowners do not receive a tax deduction for mortgage interest. With longer amortizations and higher carrying costs, you may be looking for a smarter way to approach your mortgage while building long‑term wealth.
In our latest Tax Talk Podcast, I spoke with mortgage expert Nick Cox, who outlined a practical framework—the Smith Maneuver—that aims to convert non‑deductible mortgage interest into potentially deductible investment interest. The result is tax savings you can reinvest to grow your portfolio more quickly.
What is the Smith Maneuver?
The Smith Maneuver uses a Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC) from your home. As you make regular mortgage payments, your principal falls and your HELOC room rises. You then reborrow that newly available amount and invest it in non‑registered, income‑producing assets such as dividend-paying stocks, bonds, or rental properties. With clean tracing, the HELOC interest may be deductible because the borrowing is for investment purposes.
This approach can be implemented with little or no additional monthly cash outlay when your process is set up correctly. Any tax refunds generated by deductible interest can be used to further prepay your mortgage, which accelerates the cycle.
Where the Tax Benefits Come From
The interest on money you borrow to earn investment income can be deductible when you invest in non‑registered, income‑producing assets with a reasonable expectation of income. You must keep your cashflow clearly traced and avoid commingling with your personal spending. You also need to maintain careful records, including statements, transfers, and trade confirmations.
Registered plans such as RRSPs and TFSAs do not support deductibility for this approach. Direct tracing to non‑registered investments is essential, so this strategy requires you to have good financial housekeeping.
Beyond the Foundation: Five Common Accelerators
Most households should start with the basic Smith Maneuver process, often referred to as "Plain Jane," and then add only what fits their specific situation. Once you have the foundation running smoothly, you can consider accelerators that may shorten your timeline or increase efficiency.
Cashflow Dam
Works particularly well if you hold rental properties personally. Route your rental income as prepayments on your home mortgage, then use the HELOC to pay rental expenses. This shifts more of your debt into the investment‑purpose bucket and can shorten timelines materially.
Debt Swap
Jump‑starts deductibility if you already hold a non‑registered portfolio. You sell it to prepay the mortgage, then immediately reborrow to repurchase investments. This approach does not change your net market exposure but accelerates your progress.
Cashflow Diversion
Direct surplus cash, such as bonuses or planned savings to prepay the mortgage, then reborrow to invest.
DRIP
Reinvest distributions to keep compounding, while ensuring your tracking ties distributions and balances to the investment loan.
Prime the Pump
Use an initial lump sum, such as a refund or reserve, to accelerate the early stages.
Who This Strategy May Fit
This approach is best suited for long-term planners who can commit to 10 years or more. You need to be comfortable with a disciplined and repeatable process, as well as with market volatility. Your budget should be stable enough to manage interest rate changes, and you need access to a readvanceable mortgage/HELOC with a lender setup that supports clear, separate tracking.
Understanding the Risks
Market risk means leverage amplifies gains and losses. You should align your investments with your risk profile and avoid forced selling. Interest rates and cash flow risk mean that rising rates increase carrying costs; therefore, it is essential to stress-test and maintain a buffer.
Implementing your strategy comes with risks, and you can jeopardize deductibility if you commingle funds or fail to maintain adequate documentation. Keep accounts clean and processes consistent. Liquidity risk means that some assets are harder to sell quickly, so maintaining an emergency fund outside this strategy is advisable.
Tracking Your Progress
Two key milestones help you measure success. The debt conversion point occurs when your remaining debt is fully investment‑purpose and potentially tax‑deductible. Your theoretical mortgage freedom date arrives when your portfolio value equals or exceeds the investment loan balance. Depending on returns, rates, and contributions, this can occur years earlier than your original amortization schedule.
How to Get Started
- Confirm your lender setup first. Ensure you have a readvanceable mortgage/HELOC that increases as principal falls. Map your cash flows by deciding the timing for HELOC advances and investments, and set up dedicated accounts for clean tracing.
- Select suitable investments that focus on non‑registered, income‑producing assets aligned to your goals and risk tolerance. Layer accelerators carefully—consider the Cashflow Dam if you hold rental property personally, or the Debt Swap if you already hold a non‑registered portfolio.
- Document everything by keeping statements, noting the purpose of each transfer, and reconciling monthly. Build your team by coordinating tax, mortgage, and investment advice to implement correctly and review regularly.
Do it Right With Solid Financial Housekeeping
If you are considering this strategy for your situation, thoughtful planning and clear documentation make all the difference. The Legacy team can help you evaluate your options, understand the implications, and implement confidently.
Ready to talk it through? Contact Legacy Accounting LLP to schedule a consultation.
Also, if you’re interested in learning more about leveraging your mortgage with the Smith Maneuver, contact mortgage expert Nick Cox for more information.
Want to hear more on this topic? Listen to the Tax Talk Podcast episode for additional insights.
Disclaimer
By using this website, blog or podcast, users agree as follows:
The information, services and/or products are for general information only and any reliance on the information provided therein is done at your own risk. If you make tax, accounting, investing or legal decisions after accessing this website, blog or podcast, it is recommended that you consult a qualified professional first.
The views and opinions expressed are those of the author, seller, guests or publisher and do not necessarily reflect the views of the organizations or businesses that these individuals are associated with.
Although we make strong efforts to make sure my information is accurate, we cannot always guarantee that the information on this website, blog or podcast is always correct, complete or up-to-date.
